Commercial trucking insurance is high-stakes gambling. Insurance premiums are the wager—a bet on the fleet, drivers, and safety practices. The insurance company is the "house," accepting that bet in hopes the fleet won’t incur significant claims. But what goes on behind the scenes? How do insurance companies calculate the odds, and what happens if they miscalculate? Here’s a closer look at commercial trucking insurance.

The Gamble: Premiums, Odds, and Actuaries

When setting premium rates, insurance companies rely on actuaries, the industry’s "odds makers." These experts use historical data and risk models to calculate the likelihood of claims. They analyze factors like accident frequency, claim costs, and inflation trends. Setting the minimum premium, or “bet.” Insurance brokers act as intermediaries, like a bookie, between trucking companies and insurers. They earn commissions to facilitate these relationships.

Actuarial calculations are only as reliable as the data they use. If the data is wrong the resulting odds and premiums may misrepresent actual risks. Insurers may overcharge safe trucking companies or undercharge riskier ones. These inaccuracies, if widespread, drive up premiums across the industry. Insurance companies offset losses by charging all policyholders higher rates, ensuring that everyone bears the brunt of miscalculated risks.

Actuaries vs. Underwriters: Understanding Their Roles

While actuaries work with numbers, underwriters assess a company’s specific risk factors. For instance, underwriters examine a trucking company’s Carrier Profile and safety rating. A "Satisfactory" rating typically indicates strong risk management and may lead to lower premiums, whereas a "Conditional" rating suggests potential issues, leading to stricter rates or additional charges. Now is a good time to re-read my blog, Don’t look behind the curtain! unveiling the Alberta Transportation safety scam. Unlike actuaries, underwriters consider a broader range of factors, including safety practices, maintenance programs, and driver qualifications.

Insurance Models in Canada: Public, Private, and Self-Insured

In Canada, insurance systems vary by province, with three main models: public (government-managed), private, and self-insured.

  • Public Insurance (No-Fault): Used in provinces like Manitoba, public insurance is government-managed and operates on a no-fault basis. Each driver’s insurer covers their client’s damages, regardless of fault, with caps on compensation. This often simplifies the claims process but limits potential payouts.
  • Private Insurance: Alberta and other provinces use a system, where at-fault drivers are liable for damages. This model allows for more extensive claims, including so-called "nuclear verdicts," or massive payouts in severe cases. Private insurers can deny coverage to high-risk clients, and litigation is more common as parties seek additional compensation.
  • Self-Insurance (Captive): Captive insurance allows companies to self-insure by establishing their own insurance entities, often lowering costs and retaining profits. Alberta, with new regulatory frameworks introduced in 2022, has become a leading location for captive insurance, offering tax advantages and efficient licensing for companies focused on Canadian risks.

Captive insurance can be structured as either "pure" captives for individual companies or "group" captives that pool resources across multiple companies, sharing risks and lowering costs. Captives can offer cost control, customized coverage, and better claims management—attractive benefits for companies looking to optimize their insurance options. Now think of a group of “chameleon carriers” getting together to self-insure, no risk there.

Limiting Liability: Knowing Your Policy and Exclusions

Understanding your policy and identifying gaps in your safety and maintenance program is of the upmost importance. These gaps could be used against you when approving or denying claims.  Insurance companies may scrutinize records during an incident review especially if the carrier has a black swan event. Insurance companies are looking for evidence to limit liability, looking for reasons to minimize claim payouts. Key areas for attention include:

  • Driver Compliance: Are driver files compliant? Are you monitoring your drivers’ hours-of-service? Do you deactivate drivers ELD logins so fake drivers are not used as ghost drivers?
  • Vehicle Maintenance: Comprehensive records must be maintained, including maintenance records and proof of regular safety inspections. Document re-torques when wheels are removed and at regular intervals in case of wheel separation.
  • Third Party Equipment: All third party equipment must be maintained; the carrier should clarify the responsibility and liability for its maintenance and any incidents involving it.

Complete and accurate documentation can be the difference between an insurance payout or a hefty company expense. For example, if a wheel flies off the carrier needs to be able to show regular inspections and re-torques.

In commercial trucking insurance, exclusions refer to specific situations, events, or types of damages that the insurance policy will not cover. These exclusions are important to understand, as they indicate which risks and scenarios the carrier will be financially responsible for if they occur. If you smash up your vehicle while driving impaired the insurance company doesn’t pay for a new car.

Common exclusions often include:

  • Unapproved Drivers: Accidents caused by drivers not listed on the policy are typically excluded from coverage. Unqualified or unauthorized drivers logged into ELD systems can also complicate claims. Is a driver with an invalid work permit included in this?
  • Intentional Acts and Criminal Behavior: Reckless driving, impairment, and other illegal behaviors often void coverage.
  • Improper Maintenance and Mechanical Failures: Claims arising from preventable maintenance issues may not be covered.
  • Out-of-Territory Operations: Provincially regulated carriers (intra-provincial-Alberta only) must hold a federal safety fitness certificate to operate extra-provincially (outside Alberta). There is no permit available to hold a temporary federal SFC. Out-of-province incidents may not be covered.
  • Driver Fatigue Violations: Violations of hours-of-service regulations can void coverage in case of an accident, carriers are required to monitor fatigue to minimize risks. An out-of-service driver should not be on the road.

Final Thoughts: Navigating the Insurance Gamble

The relationship between trucking companies and insurers is an intricate blend of risk, probability, and strategic management. With proactive documentation, a comprehensive safety program, and a thorough understanding of policy limits, companies can make the most of their insurance—and minimize surprises when they need it most. Lack of reliable regulatory oversight from federal and provincial governments has resulted in inaccurate carrier information, allowing trucking companies on the road that do not meet safety standards. Two things will happen, insurance companies will put pressure on regulators to do their jobs, or insurance companies will have to do enhanced compliance reviews before insuring a carrier. Insurance companies cannot use inaccurate carrier profile information and bogus TPA (third party auditors) audits anymore to determine risk.

crossmenu